Book review: the many contradictions of Mark Twain
Over the course of Ron Chernow’s lengthy (and I mean lengthy) new biography of Mark Twain, the titular subject comes to feel like a beloved house guest who overstays his welcome. Yet, once gone, he is missed terribly. Such is the paradox of Twain—a man whose contradictions exhausted and enthralled me.
Chernow’s biography focuses on Twain the man, not his literature. Beyond a few excerpts, we see little of his fiction. Instead, we see many letters. These, while fascinating, show us less of the storyteller and more of the restless, troubled soul behind the wit.
Twain was mercurial, eccentric, and frustrating. His private life was turbulent and full of sorrow—most of it self-inflicted. His letters reveal a man who could craft America’s sharpest satire yet couldn’t see the irony in his actions. This is the genius of Chernow’s choice to focus on Twain’s letters: we read on and on, eager to learn how he next shoots himself in the foot.
Twain’s most befuddling contradiction emerges from his relationship with money. Despite his success as a writer and advantageous marriage to Livy, daughter of a coal baron and heiress to a fortune, he wanted to strike it big in business. He was not immune to the get-rich-quick schemes typical of the Gilded Age (a term Twain himself coined). He invested a fortune in the Paige Compositor typesetting machine, convinced it would revolutionize the newspaper industry and make him a titan of industry. He also started his own doomed publishing company. Ultimately, his investments bankrupted his family and forced them to abandon their beloved Hartford home.
Twain paid off his creditors in 1900. Yet, as Chernow notes, “nothing could quench his thirst for speculation, not even bankruptcy.” The man who skewered human folly in his writing seemed blind to his own—after recovering from near-ruin, he plunged into another dubious venture: Plasmon, a health food product derived from skim milk he encountered in Austria. It failed.
Twain’s contradictions defined his business ventures and worldview. In later life, he advocated for African Americans and women’s rights, but was blatantly racist toward Native Americans. He was hilarious and charming in public, but cutting and vindictive in private. He loved his family dearly, but caused them pain through neglect or impulsivity. Through these paradoxes, Twain embodied America—a nation founded on freedom while enabling slavery, preaching equality while practicing discrimination.
This biography captures the complexity of America’s most celebrated humorist, justifying its considerable length. Chernow doesn’t attempt to reconcile Twain’s contradictions or excuse them—he presents them with unflinching clarity. The result is a portrait that feels more human and exasperating than the genial funny man we think we know. Like a houseguest who lingers too long, Twain may exhaust us, but his absence leaves a void of charm, humour, and intrigue that no amount of critical distance can fill.
“Mark Twain” by Ron Chernow was published on May 13, 2025, by Penguin Press, and comes in at 1,174 pages. The book was provided courtesy of the publisher for this review.
